Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Unsolicited offer from commercial business leaves homeowner confused about assessing property value

Unsolicited offer from commercial business leaves homeowner confused about assessing property value

  • 0

Q: Our neighbor sold his home to the commercial business that borders his property. He sold it after they approached him with an unsolicited offer. The neighbor was told the business wanted to remodel/redevelop the property and wanted “green space” between them and the neighborhood.

We’ve now been contacted by them too. Do you have any thoughts, do’s and don’ts, recommendations for us about how to consider any offer that is made? How does one arrive at a value for a property that would undergo a zoning change from residential to commercial?

A: Start by contacting your former neighbor to find out how much he got for his property. This information might be published online (check with your county’s recorder of deeds office), but in some areas the sales price for a home can take a while to publish or, in some cases, it’s not publicly available.

Once you know the price your neighbor got for his property, you’ll have a starting point to determine what your home is worth. It may not be an exact comparison, as one property might have amenities the other lacks, but it’s helpful. And, if you can find out what the commercial company really has in mind for the property (check with your local building department to find out what could be built if all of the properties together were zoned commercial), it will help you understand how much your property is worth to a homeowner or to a commercial builder.

Get as much information as you can about property value. Check websites but also talk with a few local real estate agents (both residential and commercial agents) and see what comes up in terms of valuations. When you interview these agents, ask them to give you an idea of what property appreciate looks like in your neighborhood, at what price they think your home should be listed and how much they think you’d get offered. Calling these agents doesn’t obligate you to hire them. You’re simply talking to them, getting to know them to see if you can work together, and evaluating how much they understand about local market conditions.

Once the commercial company makes you an offer, you’ll be able to judge whether you want to accept their offer, negotiate it based on what you’ve learned, or simply say, “No thanks.” Without the information, you can’t make an informed decision.

When it comes to zoning changes, reclassifying property from residential to commercial use can affect price. You should know that a change like that usually takes place on large parcels or many parcels all at once. For example, if you have farmland and want to build a shopping center on the property, if you have enough farm parcels grouped together, you would then go to the governmental body that handles redevelopment to petition for the land use changes. Usually in this situation, the value of the land goes up exponentially.

But in your circumstances, you are one lot of many that could be part of the rezoning. The developer will spend quite a bit of time, money and effort in putting the parcels together and working with the government officials to get the property rezoned. We don’t think it’s likely that you can value your property as if it was already rezoned, but the developer might give you a premium just to get all the land together for whatever project they are designing.

The last thing to keep in mind is what happens if you don’t sell but all of your neighbors do. You could wind up with a small parcel completely surrounded by a commercial development. If that happens, your value could tank, as there are likely to be few, if any, people who’d want to buy your property.

(Ilyce Glink is the author of “100 Questions Every First-Time Home Buyer Should Ask” (4th Edition). She is also the CEO of Best Money Moves, an app that employers provide to employees to measure and dial down financial stress. Samuel J. Tamkin is a Chicago-based real estate attorney. Contact Ilyce and Sam through their website,


Related to this story

Most Popular

  • Updated

An outdoor shower is ideal for a nice, quick wash down with fresh water after a day at the beach, dip in the pool or swim in the lake. While you’ve probably seen custom-built outdoor showers that look like they’re an indoor bathroom with hot and cold running water, we’re talking about a more modest freestanding shower unit hooked up to a garden hose outside.

  • Updated

I live in central New Hampshire, aka The Granite State. They don't call it that for nothing. My own house sits directly on top of one of the enormous granite plutons, the Meredith Porphyritic Granite. A giant piece of this solid bedrock is right next to my driveway. What a perfect place for me to live, considering my college major was geology.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News