Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Salena Zito column: As an industry faces destruction, it grows a voting coalition
Political Crossroads

Salena Zito column: As an industry faces destruction, it grows a voting coalition

  • 0
Coal Mine Opening

In 2017, a worker waited for a piece of heavy machinery to pass by at a coal mine in Friedens, Pa.


Imagine if you had a job. A good job, one that required skill and critical thinking, and had a broad impact in the community where you lived.

A job you didn’t just show up to do. It was a job you were good at and, because of it, you were able to provide a roof over your family’s head, put your children through college or help pay for their wedding and, once a year, it gave you the ability to carve out a week or two to take the family on vacation.

Now imagine that job becomes the center of political debate, one far removed from the Laurel Mountains, where this town sits. Within two decades, your profession goes from being championed by the Democratic Party and labor officials to one that they want to destroy.

John Fisher and Harvey Charles were standing outside of the Acosta Mine mechanic station in Somerset County. Both still had traces of coal dust on their hands and faces. Both just had finished their shifts, and were cleaning up themselves and their equipment. Fisher works in the mine; Charles transports the coal.

Fisher has been doing this job since 1989, when he returned home after serving four years in the Marine Corps. The 52-year-old says he travels 67 miles one way every day from his home in Cherry Tree in Clearfield County to do his job at the mine.

Here, metallurgical coal gets mined. It exclusively is used for the steel production that supports the construction of bridges, roads, highways, homes, factories, distribution centers, churches and other businesses supporting the country’s infrastructure and economy.

Fisher explains the core business here is producing and selling metallurgical coal to domestic and international steel and coke (a porous fuel) producers: “It’s a good living. I like what I do, or I would not be doing it.”

So does Charles, who says he’s been in the industry since 1987. “Right out of high school, I followed in the footsteps of my father and grandfather.”

Pick up the daily newspaper and you will find mining will get blamed for everything from the growth of the deer tick population to this past year’s mild winter (this winter has not been mild).

Several things bother Fisher and Charles regarding how others look upon those who are in the mining industry. One is the stereotype of anyone in their business either as anti-intellectual or anti-clean environment. The former they consider insulting, the latter ridiculous.

The other thing that gets under their skin is when politicians flippantly suggest they quickly can get another job. U.S. Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg recently said people who lost their jobs to climate justice might find a climate-conscious job.

And President Joe Biden suggested coal miners just should learn to code. This past year in New Hampshire, in the middle of a brag of how former President Barack Obama had placed him in charge of judging what the jobs of the future would be, he said, “Anybody who can go down 3,000 feet in a mine can sure as hell learn to program as well.”

It still is astounding to witness the contempt and disdain politicians and the press have toward the lives and livelihoods of people who aren’t like them, people who don’t live in their ZIP codes or attend the same universities they did.

People who work with their hands don’t start a conversation by asking you where you work. It is rare to find anyone here who would say your profession is irredeemable and that you need to do something they find worthy. Traditionally, when a job or an industry has a problem, they work on fixing it or correcting it rather than destroying it.

People often asked after the 2020 election what will happen with the Donald Trump voters (Fisher and Charles voted for him twice). The thing is this complex conservative populist coalition existed long before it helped catapult Trump to the presidency in 2016.

His win, in part, was the result of a culture that became detached from the people they served in various institutions, whether it was the government, the entertainment industry or the college campus. Many people ultimately rejected all of them.

But if you never understood that, if you always thought it was about Trump, you never understood who they were and why they vote the way they do.

And you never understood how someone who lives in the suburbs of Arizona or Kenosha, Wis., or Miami could have anything in common with someone who works the mines in Appalachia. And you didn’t understand that because you didn’t care to, because you hoped for its destruction.

There will be two endings to this story. The first is industries such as coal or shale, or the creation of pipelines, will continue to get attacked and dismantled, costing people their jobs.

And the other ending is this coalition will grow — despite the press incorrectly believing one person caused it and having the audacity to think they have the power to dismantle it.

Salena Zito is a CNN political analyst, and a staff reporter and columnist for the Washington Examiner.

© 2021,

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News